Same paycheck, same benefits, more money lands in the account. Here is the plain-English walkthrough.
Every dealer eventually runs into the same wall. The service team wants a raise. The P&L has no room for a raise. You are already paying more in benefits and workers’ comp than you were three years ago. The market rate keeps climbing. Somewhere between that pressure and the next pay period, a GM starts losing techs over fifty cents an hour.
There is a lever most dealers have not pulled. It sits in the IRS code, not in the comp plan. It is called a Section 125 pre-tax premium, and when it is set up correctly it puts 2–5% more take-home pay in every enrolled employee’s paycheck without the dealership writing a bigger check.
Today, most employees pay for their benefit premiums after their paycheck has already been taxed. The IRS calculates their federal income tax and FICA on the full gross wage, and then the premium gets deducted from what is left. The employee is paying tax on money they are about to hand right back for coverage.
A Section 125 plan — named for the section of the tax code that authorizes it — moves that premium in front of the tax calculation. The taxable wage drops by the amount of the premium. FICA and federal income tax are calculated on the smaller number. The employee’s check gets heavier. The dealership’s matching FICA on that same dollar gets smaller.
Run the numbers on a service advisor earning $65,000 a year with a family premium in the plan. After the pre-tax treatment, their take-home pay typically climbs 2–5%. On average, that is about $600 more per employee per year landing in the checking account. For a 60-person rooftop, that is around $36,000 in take-home lift distributed across the team, and you did not spend a dollar of payroll to produce it.
Your team is going to notice. The first full pay period after enrollment is the one where the F&I director walks in and asks why his paycheck jumped.
Because FICA is calculated on the reduced wage, the dealership’s employer-side FICA match on that premium dollar goes away. Multiply that across every enrolled employee and the payroll tax line on your quarterly 941 gets smaller. The plan pays for itself and then keeps paying.
This is not a deferral. It is not a rebate. The tax savings are real and structural, because the employee’s W-2 wages are calculated correctly under IRS rules the same way a 401(k) contribution would be. W-2 reporting, retirement contributions, and overtime calculations are all handled correctly inside the plan.
The pre-tax premium is a payroll-treatment change. It does not touch your medical carrier, your broker, your renewal calendar, or your plan design. You are not moving carriers. You are not re-quoting. You are not going to sit through another enrollment roadshow. The Section 125 structure is layered in alongside whatever you already offer.
Elysian’s plans are structured with tax-advisory oversight from a national law firm that specializes in this area. Every dealership receives a plan document drafted for its specific situation, so the payroll treatment and eligibility rules are documented before the first premium runs.
A traditional raise costs the dealership more than the employee receives. A pre-tax premium delivers more to the employee than it costs the dealership — in fact, it saves the dealership money on the matching payroll tax. Same benefits. Same coverage. Same medical plan. The money just lands in a better place.
If you want the Section 125 math for your store, send us your headcount and we will build the model.
Tell us your headcount and we will model the take-home lift and the FICA savings.
Get the Model